← Back to all diffs
NPR

Trump calls SCOTUS tariffs decision 'deeply disappointing' and lays out path forward

View original article →
+430 words added -436 words removed
− Franco Ordoñez President Donald Trump speaks in Washington, DC.
+ Franco Ordoñez President Trump speaks in Washington, D.C.
− Alex Wong/Getty Images North America hide caption President Trump called the Supreme Court's decision against his sweeping use of tariffs "deeply disappointing" and slammed the members of the court who ruled against him.
+ Alex Wong/Getty Images hide caption President Trump called the Supreme Court's decision against his sweeping use of tariffs "deeply disappointing" and slammed the members of the court who ruled against him.
Trump called the justices who opposed his tariffs "fools" and "lapdogs," charging that they were acting because of liberal partisanship, though three of those ruling against him were appointed by Republican presidents and two were Trump appointees. "I think it is deeply disappointing, and I'm ashamed of certain members of the court, absolutely ashamed for not having the courage to do what's right for our country," he said.
− The court – in a 6 to 3 decision - found that a law known as the International Emergency Economic Powers Act does not authorize the president to impose tariffs.
+ The court, in a 6-to-3 decision, found that a law known as the International Emergency Economic Powers Act does not authorize the president to impose tariffs.
− The ruling was the president's most significant defeat at the Supreme Court since he returned to office, and threatens to upend one of Trump's favorite and most powerful tools of his economic and foreign policy agenda.
+ The ruling was the president's most significant defeat at the Supreme Court since he returned to office, and it threatens to upend one of Trump's favorite and most powerful tools of his economic and foreign policy agenda.
The decision injects even more uncertainty into the future of tariffs, but Trump made clear that he has no plans on giving up on his agenda. Calling it his "favorite word in the dictionary," Trump has repeatedly credited his use of tariffs with helping him stop wars and pressure world leaders to bend to U.S. interests. He boasted about the economic benefits.
− A recent Congressional Budget Office report found that tariffs were expected to help reduce the deficits by about $3 trillion over a decade.
+ A recent Congressional Budget Office report found that tariffs were expected to help reduce the deficit by about $3 trillion over a decade.
But that same report found that U.S.
− consumers - not foreign companies - were paying the vast majority of that money.
+ consumers — not foreign companies — were paying the vast majority of that money.
But while talking with reporters Friday, Trump sought to put a positive spin on the court decision. He said that it would provide certainty for the U.S. economy and that he plans to seek alternatives, which he laid out specifically. "Their decision's incorrect. But it doesn't matter, because we have very powerful alternatives that have been approved by this decision," he said.
− Trump cited a dissent written by Justice Brett Kavanaugh who listed laws that the administration could pursue, including "the Trade Act of 1974 sections 122, 201, 301, and the Tariff Act of 1930 section 338." He acknowledged that those processes may be more cumbersome, but had stronger legal standing.
+ Trump cited a dissent written by Justice Brett Kavanaugh, who listed laws that the administration could pursue, including "the Trade Act of 1974, sections 122, 201, 301, and the Tariff Act of 1930, section 338." He acknowledged that those processes may be more cumbersome, but had stronger legal standing.
− He also cited Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974, that allows the president to impose tariffs to address trade deficits.
+ He also cited Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974, which allows the president to impose tariffs to address trade deficits.
− But those tariffs are limited to 15%, and only for 150 days, after which Congress would have to approve them.
+ But those tariffs are limited to 15% and for only 150 days, after which Congress would have to approve them.
− "While I am sure that they did not mean to do so, the Supreme Court's decision today made the President's ability to both regulate trade and impose tariffs more powerful and more crystal clear, rather than less.
+ "While I am sure that they did not mean to do so, the Supreme Court's decision today made the president's ability to both regulate trade and impose tariffs more powerful and more crystal clear, rather than less.
I don't think they meant that. I'm sure they didn't," Trump said.
− And he said he would sign an executive order today to continue certain tariffs under alternative authorities, including adding a "10% global tariff." That rule would also eventually need approval from Congress, after 150 days, which could be difficult with an election approaching.
+ And he said he would sign an executive order later Friday to continue certain tariffs under alternative authorities, including adding a "10% global tariff." That order would also eventually need approval from Congress, after 150 days, which could be difficult with an election approaching.
− Republicans are facing pressure from constituents about high costs and the business community that is afraid to invest with all the economic uncertainty.
+ Republicans are facing pressure from constituents about high costs and a business community that is afraid to invest with all the economic uncertainty.
− A recent NPR/Marist poll finds that a majority of Americans – 56 percent - feel tariffs or fees on imported products from other countries hurts the U.S.
+ A recent NPR/Marist poll finds that a majority of Americans — 56% — feel tariffs or fees on imported products from other countries hurts the U.S.
economy. The former Senate majority leader, Sen.
− Mitch McConnell praised the Supreme Court's decision.
+ Mitch McConnell, praised the Supreme Court's decision.
"Congress' role in trade policy, as I have warned repeatedly, is not an inconvenience to avoid," the Kentucky Republican said.
− "If the executive would like to enact trade policies that impact American producers and consumers, its path forward is crystal clear: convince their representatives under Article 1" of the Constitution." But Trump, who has expressed frustration with gridlock in Congress, expressed confidence that he would continue to be able to employ tariffs unilaterally.
+ "If the executive would like to enact trade policies that impact American producers and consumers, its path forward is crystal clear: Convince their representatives under Article I" of the Constitution.
+ But Trump, who has expressed frustration with gridlock in Congress, expressed confidence that he would continue to be able to employ tariffs unilaterally.
"Foreign countries that have been ripping us off for years are ecstatic," Trump said.
− They are so happy and they're dancing in the streets.
+ "They are so happy and they're dancing in the streets.
But they won't be dancing for long. That I can assure you." Sponsor Message Become an NPR sponsor